A little about us

Hi, we are Stephanie Kaat and Keegan Waggett, and this is our bakery. We started The Looking Glass Bakery with our love for food and desire to make people happy through dessert. As the seasons change, so do our flavors. The Looking Glass Bakery strives to offer you the best cheesecake and desserts around with a focus on sourcing local ingredients. You can find our menu online, but we encourage our customers to contact us with any special requests or for allergen info. We love creating customized orders for birthdays, weddings, or just because it's a Tuesday!

Since we do not have a conventional retail location, we mainly sell our desserts through special orders, catering, weddings, and by partnering with local restaurants/shops. We encourage you to check out our calendar online for our locations with our Food Cart or contact us to place an order for catering or special events to the Madison area. 

Find our Products

We sell our products at the following locations:

  • Alchemy-slices of cheesecake, cakes, pies, and tarts

  • Rockhound Brewing Company-rotating variety of desserts

  • Metcalfe West-packaged gluten free cookies

  • Metcalfe Hilldale- packaged gluten free cookies




With custom flavors and unique flavors we strive to create a once in a life time experience. To get started schedule your free complimentary tastings today!

Upcoming Events 

Check out our calendar to see the latest food cart events and news!